Mind Trap #4: Labeling


Reader,

It took me 10 seconds to judge a stranger at the gym.
​
​What is that guy doing? What a try hard. You think you’re so tough. You’re not impressing anyone.​
​
That’s what was running through my head as I watched this guy loudly grunt through a set with terrible form before slamming his weights down to finish.
​
Confession: my judgments aren’t limited to the gym. I do this a lot. I watch how people act, listen to what they say, notice how they dress or drive or play pickleball, and within seconds I’ve decided exactly who they are.
​
There’s a name for this. It’s a mind trap called labeling / mislabeling.
​
Here’s how to do it if you want to give it a try: take one small snippet of someone’s life and turn it into a verdict of their character. Don’t worry about real evidence (their heart, their story, what they’re actually like). Ignore any possibility apart from your smug, shallow judgements. Do this and you’ve mastered the mind trap of labeling.

The way out is to ask yourself, “What’s the evidence for my judgment of this person?” Most of the time there isn’t any. When you realize that, move forward by coming up with a few other stories that could explain what you’re seeing.

Going back to the guy in the gym, there are a handful of questions I could have asked:

  • Maybe he’s new and no one ever showed him proper form?
  • Maybe he’s fighting his way back from something
  • Maybe the gym is the one place he feels strong this week

​
Staying open to people is a choice that I’m learning to make. How about you

You are loved.

I am for you.

You've got this.

Jake

Dr. Jake Smith Jr.

I'm a faith-fueled formation coach & speaker who develops fully-formed leaders to become who they truly are and live with no regrets.

Read more from Dr. Jake Smith Jr.

Reader, One of the core principles in Plumline's Living with Heart program is that there are no bad feelings. We're by no means the first or only people to teach this. However, it's vital part of our work because many people were (and are) raised to believe that some feelings are bad. This is especially true for those of us who grew up in the church. Christians are often told that their anger and sadness are signs of sin or deficiencies in their character. But that's not true. Our feelings...

Reader, The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh, Disney's adaptation of the A. A. Milne classic, is full of characters caught up in mind traps. Rabbit is a professional labeler, defining his fellow characters according to isolated incidents. Piglet is enmired in external control fallacies, convinced that he has no control over his life or circumstances. Tigger is prone to all-or-nothing thinking, alternating between flying high and diving into the depths of despair. And then there's Eeyore. He...

Reader, "If you ain't first, you're last!" You might recognize this quote from Will Ferrell and Adam McKay's comedy, Talladega Nights: The Ballad of Ricky Bobby. These words are the driving force behind Ricky Bobby's life. He first heard them from his absent deadbeat dad during a school career day when Ricky was ten years old. Throughout his adult life, they continue to haunt him, influencing every decision he makes. This mantra is the epitome of the first mind trap I want to introduce you...